913 replies, Replies 541 to 550

Why do young people like socialism so much?

HelpCop wrote:

1. You're a good student. You study hard and burn the midnight oil. Other students in your class aren't like that. But, no problem, right? Well, in this case, the grading system operates under a socialistic system.
You get back your report card and to your surprise you're given all C's..... Why? Because the grading system operates under a socialistic system, that's why. The A's you make are thrown in with the class average of others who are failures (= F) in order that others can benefit from your hard work. There is no incentive for the other parasites to get off their lazy azz and study - they're content with C's. If they actually got the grade they deserve, the school would kick them out into the street.
It's failures like those that need to hit the g0€€dΩmm ground and bounce....

I don't think that analogy tracks for the following reason: Grades are evaluations of performance, and medical treatment is a resource.

The analogy would be closer like this: You only have one pencil. Most of the other kids in class have three or four pencils and there are a couple of kids in class that have fifty pencils a piece.

You work hard and get good grades, but on the final exam, which counts for 70 percent of your grade, your pencil breaks as you write your name on the top.

It's more than fair for the teacher, in a case like that, to demand that one of the kids with fifty pencils give you one, and maybe an extra for just in case.

Or you can just say "tough luck, you should just, you know, HAVE more pencils. Guess you're failure."

Unfortunately, pencil insurance is really expensive and our student in this scenario can't afford it cus his job doesn't provide it and he's just barely making ends meet and now it's too effin' late to get pencil insurance and he's going to fail and then..he DIES, cus that's what happens to a lot of people who can't afford health insurance.

The fact is...we all get sick...and sometimes its' worse than others. My point with the auto insurance above is sincere. I think it's outrageous that you're required to get it...you pay thousands of dollars into it that you likely never need.

Health insurance isn't like that. We all need it and use it all the time. Yet when Obamacare first rolled out when I pointed that out to people they were like, "Auto insurance? OF COURSE I NEED THAT! But don't make me get really low cost or free health insurance, it's not right!" There is an obvious contradiction in that way of thinking.

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

Anonymous wrote:
Go away lano. You obviously are grandstanding for your lefty friends. You are incapable of answering a simple question without putting a spin on it. Very typical of lefty tactics.
Your controlling condescenion isnt appreciated.

Ok, I don't really care what you appreciate, sir, just realize this is a public forum and you can't kick me out because you don't like what I have to say.

I'm the one who's asking a basic question that you really should have an simple answer to if you aren't just trolling: What do you mean when you say "socialism."

If your question is really that simple, why are you asking it? Just post your opinion instead of asking a clearly rhetorical question.

The fact that you're unwilling to really think about what you're asking kind of shows that it really wasn't an honest question open to different opinions on it. Sounds more like you're fishing for confirmation of your own views or just trolling.

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

Maybe it would be more succinct to ask it this way: So you're saying the poster is really asking is: "Why do young people like leaning on the government politic as a benefactor for your needs wants and desires so much?"

That would have been a much clearer way to ask the question without getting into a debate about what socialism is and is not, which is something admittedly there can be a philosophical difference on, even among self-professed socialists (of which I am not one).

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

I'm just saying that we need to be clear on what way say and how we mean it

HelpCop wrote:

Well, Lano, the standard definition of Socialism is to lean on the government politic as a benefactor for your needs wants and desires.

The problem with this way of defining the word is you used the word "standard." If by standard you mean the dictionary definition, this is just incorrect. "standard definition" does not mean "how many people use the word."

When you use the word in a way that is incompatible with the ACTUAL standard definition, then it's no surprise when confusion as to what is meant arises.

Another point of clarification: by the literal definition of what you said, then all the things I mentioned ARE socialist. The government disperses all of those benefits, and they are definitely all either needs, wants, or desires.

I think what you really mean is: Socialism is when I have to pay taxes for things that directly benefit some parts of the population, but not all those who are paying taxes on it.

Before you accuse me of assuming things, I'm going to point out that I said "I think" that's what you mean, please don't accuse me of making assumptions where I have actually made none.

Anyway, nothing you said really clarifies what I am asking, which is what supposedly socialist policies does the poster mean. Because if you can't even define what you are asking about, we're kinda talking about nothing.

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

BananaLlama wrote:

The funny thing is that our healthcare really isn’t that different. We still pay for it in monthly deductions from wages. It’s like insurance but as a tax. The good thing is if you’re not working you still get healthcare. At least we don’t have to worry about being in debt if we break a leg!

Apparently the UK also pays less for The same medication than US do.

Do you have to pay co-pays, deductibles, and does the government only pay the large majority of the cost of big bills, and not cover other things at all?

Cus thats how my insurance company works.

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

Anonymous wrote:
Ok lano. You are hell bent on giving a spin to your response.
Its Ok. I asked the same question on quora and got brillent answers.
You ever consider being a politician?

It's not spin, it's a simple question of clarification.

Maybe you don't consider the basic public amenities of saftey nets i listed as socialist policies. If that is the case i am just asking you to specify what you mean when you say that.

I'm happy that people in quora understood you perfectly.

- written
Im more depressed than ever today.

Beer is good. I feel that way whether i am depressed or not though.

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

Anonymous wrote:
Lano. I hate to break it to you. You are not a young person anymore.
I was refering to uni students.
The 18 to 22 crowd.
Ypu read way more into the post.
It was a sincere question.
No spins. It wasnt even a rant.

I think i took it as a sincere question and replied addressing the problems with the question. If I did not answer appropriately, it's because as it stands, the question comes off as quite vague for the reasons i mentioned.

In other words, you might as well ask why most everyone is socialist if you're not going to specify which socialist policies you are presuming are especially popular with college students.

If you're asking a question honestly you also have to be open to the idea that maybe the question, as posed, will not give a meaningful answer.

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

Thats the funny thing llama, you're european concerned about socialism while people on the right in the usa will look at europe and call you all irresponsible socialists.

It just illustrates that the term in most public discourse is disconnected from its real meaning and is just used as a rhetorical device to make people think of the soviet union. If you're for ANY form of public healthcare, you're with Stalin! Puh leez

- written
Why do young people like socialism so much?

Questions are good but if this is more than a rant, the right question must be asked.

I'm in my early thirties, so i count as young? What about elementary school kids?

And what do you mean by socialism? The usa has tons of socialist policies that no one (or at least not most) seem to have a problem with. Public schools, public libraries, social security, unemployment benefits, the government of most states requiring you to have auto insurance if you want to drive, and others i can't think of right now.

Probably you have none of these things in mind when you say socialism, but are simply aping rhetoric that a pundit is spouting who could care less if your child has a basic education.

The only way a debate like this becomes grounded in reality is by talking about specific problems with specific policies. Otherwise both sides are swiming in a sea of idealisti nonesense.

- written